top of page
The Need For Home Water Purification

The Need For Home Water Purification
These days, in many localities, drinking water quality is lacking because of a host of toxins that are potentially dissolved in them.  
To avoid these contaminants, such as ALUMINUM, CHROMIUM, MERCURY, LEAD, FLUORIDE, HERBICIDES, PASTESIDES, Disinfectants like chlorine, chloramine, and chlorine dioxide that can kill vitamin E and other fatty acids (that help keep your skin healthy), and a few other contaminants like bacteria and other pathogens, people resort to two prime
purification methods - distillation and Reverse Osmosis (RO), with the objective of getting PURE DRINKING WATER! Not only that drinking purified water is better for your skin and helps to prevent aging symptoms, but it could also help you to reduce the risk of having major health issues and protect your family from harmful contaminants.

Water distillers and reverse osmosis systems are two methods of water purification. There is no doubt that water distillation would produce reliable clean water “While both methods remove contaminants, distilled water is purer due to the boiling process”. Still, there is one unresolved issue with home distillation devices - post distillation cleaning! Just watch this short video and see what’s left after distilling 1 gallon of tap water (min 0:40), and what it takes to clean it. Furthermore, time and again, you have to refill the distiller.
The Reverse Osmosis (RO) alternative requires far lower maintenance, and produces a very good quality of purified water at a very low price, provided that the system selection and maintenance are performed with some basic knowledge of the quality and operational parameters that determine the final results.
 
TDS - RO Water PURITY Measure
Total Dissolved Solids (TDS) Level
Asking ChatGPT "what measurement is best for water purity" - it brings TDS at the top of the list. Don't be misled by those who claim "The hard truth is, TDS is not an accurate indication of water quality". "A TDS meter will detect any charged ions in the water, which could include positively charged ions such as calcium, sodium, magnesium, and potassium or negatively charged ions such as carbonate, hydrogen carbonate, chloride, sulfate, and nitrate".

Don't be confused between water quality (e.g. water enriched with minerals + alkaline) and water purity!!! TDS is a good measure for water purity! Distilled water has a TDS of 0.5 ppm or less, so to put it simply, the lower the TDS the better the water purity! Most people who look for home purification systems are motivated by the need to remove potential water contaminants such as MERCURY, LEAD... HERBICIDES, PESTICIDES... This is the hard part (as explained below) because the size of many of the metallic contaminants is in the range of 0.0001 to 0.001 micronRemoving such particles from the water requires a membrane pore size not larger than 0.0001 micron. As an example, lead ion atoms are 0.000154 micrometers. This membrane pore size, makes it also very effective in the removal of pathogens such as Viruses that range in size from about 0.02 – 0.5 microns and bacterial cells that are in the range of 1 to 10 microns in length and from 0.2 to 1 micron in width". 

Once you get pure water - it's easy to implement the addition of the desired minerals and some alkalinity, as can be found in most water purification systems, most notably RO ones.

 

RO Systems Filtration Structure Mechanism
RO systems are actually built with two water treatment phases: 
Phase 1 - Water purification, with a membrane filter as its last element. It is a challenge to Keep membranes with pore size of 0.0001 from getting clogged, and still provide the membrane surface area for a water flow at a reasonable rate. That is why quality RO systems come with "Auto Flash/Self Cleaning" mechanisms (Read more below).
Phase 2 - Water enrichment, adding alkalinity and mineralization. This phase is easily obtained even with some add-on filters. 

So, how do we know what is the purity of the RO system if the water produced are enriched with alkalinity and minerals? Simple, we obtains the added TDS value of these filters and subtract it from the TDS reading that we obtain from the system's output water. Here is an example of such increase: "This filter (iSpring FA15) is capable of increasing the pH value of the RO water by 0.5 to 0.8. The Alkaline filter compensates for the lost minerals eliminated in the RO process and restores these minerals back into the pure water. These minerals being restored will slightly increase the TDS value, normally between 10-20 ppm" 

Note, a search on the web for "RO desired TDS level" would bring a wide range - somewhere between 50 to 300 ppm, saying that "TDS level lower than 50 ppm has no nourishing impact on the human body". Others claim that TDS levels in the 50-150 range, are considered ideal, hinting for the benefits of the minerals left in the water. As we explained above all these recommendations ignore the main reason for the installation of the RO system in the first place - getting clean (pure) water. Having a RO system producing output water with TDS level of 100 could leave a large uncertainty about the toxins and pathogens removal capability of that system.

bottomline - try to get as pure (low TDS) water as you can from the RO purification phase ("behind" the membrane) and then have them enriched with alkaline and mineralizing filters. If your RO system pure water TDS level starts to rise, without a significant TDS change of the input water, it's a good indication that it's time to replace the "pre-membrane" filters and/or the membrane itself .

RO System Selection
To start with, you have to decide if you look for a system with or without a storage tank.   

 

Tank Or Tankless RO System
RO system storage tank is added to regulate the water output flow rate, and eliminates the system's dependency on the system's water input pressure, without the need for a booster pump. The storage tank comes with air pressure of 7 - 8 psi which stabilises the flow of the system's output water. The main issues to be considered regarding a RO system with storage tank option are:

  1. It takes space that is not always available in the cabinet below the sink,

  2. Contaminants "creeping" problem. This is a problem with both, a tank or tankless RO systems. This creeping is the diffusion of ions (contaminants) through the membrane into the pure water side of the membrane when the system is idle, balancing the contaminates osmotic pressure "before" and "after" the membrane. Avoiding this problem is simple with a tankless system by letting some "pure" water flow to the sink for 5-10 seconds before starting to fill your cup. Understandably, this option is not available if the water from the membrane flows into the tank and mix with the water stored in it. Another option is to have a system that supports the auto flush feature (Read more below).

  3. If there are some pathogens that somehow got through the water purification phase, be it because of inadequate filters or delayed replacement of the purification filters, and if the water remains for a prolonged period of time (9 - 10 days) without being "changed", the storage tank may become a breeding ground for those pathogens. A different source claims: "The dirty secret is: the inside of a residential reverse osmosis tank accumulates and breed heterotrophic bacteria over time. Heterotrophic bacteria are microorganisms that use organic carbon as food". The growth rate of these pathogens is a matter of "discussion", as revealed by a search on the web using the keywords "how long does it take bacteria to proliferate in RO storage tank". Still, there is no doubt that pathogen growth is an issue with RO systems storage tanks.

  4. Contaminants removal effectiveness of filters and most importantly the membrane filter, depends on the feed water pressure - generally speaking, the higher the pressure the higher the contaminants removal. Most "storage tank" RO systems come without a booster pump which makes the effectiveness of contaminants removal dependent on the feed water supply pressure. That is why most RO storage tank vendors would recommend a booster pump if their system does not include one and the feed water pressure is less than 0.2 MPa (2 bar / 29.01 psi).

 

Tankless RO Systems - These systems include a booster pump that generates the right water pressure for a good functioning of the membrane filter and for "sufficient" water output flow rate - which means that tankless RO systems need a power supply to operate. Also, this booster pump and some additional electrical elements needed for its control, make these RO systems more expensive, compared with RO systems with storage tanks and similar daily water output.

TDS - RO Water Quality Parameter
RO System Selection
Tank Or Tankless RO System
RO Systems Filtration Structure Mechanism
RO System Selection Criteria
Tankless RO Systems
Contaminants "creeping" problem
Above 95% “stable rejection rate
Feed and pure water TDS display
GAC and CTO filters Composition
Self Cleaning
Last Phase Filter
Pure Water Flow Rate

RO System Selection Criteria

Note: As explained above, we consider water purification as RO systems most important feature, therefore, we recommend to consider the first two criteria on the list below as the most important ones. The rest of the criteria are "good to have" but their impact on water purity is indirect.

  1. Above 95% "Stable Rejection Rate": Water purification capability of RO system is measured by its “Stable Rejection Rate”. This rate refers to the consistent and reliable percentage of contaminants or impurities that the system can effectively remove from its feed water. So if you have a system that provides a 95% rejection rate and if you have a TDS reading of 500 before the RO membrane, your TDS reading after membrane filtration should be around 25.

    • To validate the rejection rate of your RO system you need to measure both - the system’s pure water TDS (Total Dissolved Solids) and the system’s feed water TDS (Pure TDS/Feed TDS X 100).

    • Note: some vendors would rate the rejection rate of their system as “Above 90%...”, or “Up to 99%...” - these are ambiguous ratings.    

  2. GAC and CTO Filters Composition - it's important that these filters are made from 100% coconut shell carbon, with iodine value of above 1000.

    • Coconut shell carbon in GAC (Granular Activated Carbon) and CTO (Chlorine removal, Taste, and Odor) filters, has many advantages such as high mechanical strength (strong adhesion), and high pore volume. 

    • Iodine value of above 1000 - The higher the iodine value the greater is the filter’s adsorption capacity. Coconut shell carbon activated material with iodine value of above 1000 are translated to higher ability to capture and retain impurities, such as organic compounds and chlorine (Chlorine and chloramine are the major disinfectants used in public water systems).

  3. Pure Water Flow Rate - The flow rate of systems with storage tank is determined by the storage tank internal pressure and the tank volume, whereas the flow rate from tankless systems is determined by the entire system’s construction and consequently its price. For tankless systems, look for flow rate of no less than 1.5 liter/min.  

  4. Feed and Pure Water TDS Display - Water purity is greatly affected by the system’s feed water contamination (TDS) level - the higher the feed water TDS, the higher the pure water TDS. Feed water TDS also significantly impacts the replacement frequency of the pre membrane filters and the membrane itself. A rise of pure water TDS, without a TDS rise of the feed water, is a most important indication for a need for filter replacement since most, if not all home RO systems vendors do not specify a predefined replacement period but would rather give a “range” like: “12-24 months or 1300 gallons whichever comes first”. Some systems have indicators that signal when filters need changing but these indicators are activated by the system's predefined usage time rather than the actual effectiveness of each filter. Having a pure water TDS display enables to determine the need for replacement by tracking the pure water TDS level, taking action when you notice a rise in that level, that is not related to a TDS rise in the feed water. A RO system with feed water TDS display will greatly assist you with this determination.

  5. Filter replacement job - Read the User’s Manual to see how easy it would be to install the system and later replace the filters, to reduce/eliminate the need for professional help for the system's installation and maintenance.

  6. Self Cleaning (also called Auto Flush) this mechanism automatically “power flushes” the membrane upon post installation initial start-up and then subsequently for 10-20 seconds every couple of hours of accumulated output water flow or a period of “no use”. This turbulent water action removes organic and inorganic contaminants from the membrane, thereby extending the membrane efficacy and life expectancy, ensuring consistency of water purity over time, thereby extending the membrane and other filters’ functional life span. Self cleaning mechanism is also important to eliminate (or minimise) the TDS creep problem as we mentioned above.

  7. Feed Water Low/High Pressure Regulating Valves - these valves will protect the system from extreme low and high feed water pressure. Note, many RO systems’ installation instructions would read:

    • “The operating pressure in your home should be tested over a 24 hour period to attain the maximum pressure. If it is above 0.63 MPa (6.3 bar / 91.4 psi), then a pressure regulator is necessary". 

    • It’s a good recommendation with one small problem - cost! Most hydrostatic tests cost between $250 to $500.

    • Even if the results of the pressure testing are within the system's pre-specified operating pressure range, there is still the problem of pressure fluctuations, fluctuations that without the regulator valves, could damage the system.

  8. Waste Water Ratio - it is the amount of water wasted for every gallon of purified water produced, expressed as pure to waste ratio. Look for an efficiency ratio of above 1:1 ratio.

  9. Phthalates and Bisphenol-A (BPA) Free - food grade plastic tubes and components - most of the RO systems are made with plastic materials. Some plastic materials tend to leach toxins such as Phthalates and Bisphenol A, into the water that they come in contact with. Make sure that the RO tubes and components of the system that you want to purchase are made of food grade PE, ABS or stainless steel materials. Read on this page more about Phthalates and Bisphenol A in plastics.

    • Note! This criterion is most important! Most RO system vendors are now complying with this requirement. Still we strongly recommend that you validate that the system of your choice complies with this requirement.​

  10. Last Phase Filter - in spite of the attention given to this feature, driven by profit motivation, the importance of the minerals added to the pure water with this filter is rather marginal. Even if we assume that a person would consume 4 liters/day, the table below clearly shows that the minerals we acquire from our drinking water is marginal when compared to what we have to acquire on a daily basis from our foods. The most important feature of this filter is the alkalinity that it adds to make the water tastier, and the added minerals are "a small bonus" to that feature. This filter should bring the output water pH to above 8 given that for most people, water with a pH of around 8 to 8.5 tastes better than water with a lower pH as the pH of pure water is around 7.

Minerals in Water.png
Phthalates and Bisphenol-A (BPA) Free
Low/High Pressure Regulator Valves
Waste Water Ratio
Filter Replacement Job
bottom of page